
Beasley, who had rented another apartment to move away from Chestnut, confronted Chestnut at his dry-cleaning store on E. Main Street on the Near East Side after hearing that Chestnut had hit one of his children.
Chestnut was charged with second-degree murder after he fatally shot Beasley at the store. Chestnut claimed self-defense and was acquitted a year later.
The Dispatch reported after the shooting: “People gathered at the shooting scene. More and more came. Rocks, bricks and other objects began to smash car windows. Police moved in and broke up the crowd … several times.
“By early evening, the most optimistic thought they had things under control.”
That changed shortly before 8 p.m., when Chestnut’s store and a nearby building were torched. Responding firefighters were pelted with rocks and bottles by an angry crowd.
“All police from East Side precincts were ordered into the area,” The Dispatch reported. “The riot was on.”
Stores were looted, 35 to 40 fires set, more than 200 people were arrested, and one man was killed: George Stultz, a 53-year-old white member of a crime watch, was shot by a sniper as he helped police direct traffic.
The Ohio National Guard was called in about 10 p.m. By 1:30 a.m., the riot was under control. Two days later, National Guard members were withdrawn, and the city coped with the aftermath.
John Hawkins, a black friend of the white sniper victim, said after his funeral: “The things that have happened here this week … it’s foolishness on both parts, that’s what. Awful, terrible foolishness.”